Hand Tools on the Cheap- A Scrounger's Guide

by Lisa Kadonaga


Until a couple of years ago, I never used to bother with yard sales. A waste of time rooting through other people's overpriced junk, right? But ever since I got interested in armouring, I've started checking out second-hand stores and garage sales. There are several reasons why it's worth keeping these sources in mind when you're trying to acquire armour-making tools.

1) Good tools can cost a lot of money. It can be difficult to find reasonably-priced items that aren't going to go to pieces on you. My favourite example is the el cheapo tubular hacksaw stocked by a lot of discount stores. After breaking several of these, I finally realized that what Terry Pratchett said was true -- I wasted thirty dollars when I could have bought a more expensive but sturdier type that would be good for at least ten years of heavy use. Many tools put up for sale are flimsy, but if you look carefully, you can often find good stuff at decent prices.

2) I still have qualms about grinding a brand-new tool into different shape, or sawing off part of the handle. Even though I could get a cheap hammer made in China or Pakistan for only six or seven bucks, which is not much of a saving over a $3 model from the 1950s, I have fewer regrets about filing the face of the $3 hammer into a dome. Besides, it's so beat-up that some of the work's already been done for me. And if I make a mistake, I haven't thrown away quite as much money.

3) By re-using old tools you're not only recycling, but you're also learning a lot about fixing things. From now on, if I chip the edge of a chisel or break a hammer handle, I'll have it back in working order in a few hours. There are still places where running out and buying a replacement isn't an option -- basic tool repair skills can be very useful.

(see also: An Introduction to the Skill of Making Armour )


Some Things for Fixing Old Tools

Rust-removing chemicals. The people who share your dwelling will appreciate it if the tools you bring into the house are clean and dry. If you are concerned about environmental contamination, you can get a lot of muck off using dish soap, vinegar, and old scrubbing brushes (toothbrushes etc.). If you're going to remove the wooden parts anyway, immersion in warm water is not a problem. Getting water out of complicated inner workings (e.g. crank drills) is no problem if you zap them with a hair dryer, or put them in the oven on LOW heat.

Various grades of sandpaper. You can put a surprisingly high polish on metal just using 400-grade.

Files and rasps (and a wire brush to clean them). An all-purpose half-round file can be used on flat or curved surfaces, and a round "rat-tail" file about 6 to 8 inches long (around 15-20 cm) is perfect for getting into the crannies.

Heavy mineral oil. This is non-toxic, less prone to staining, and available at most drugstores. Especially if you're dealing with high-carbon steel, coat the metal with it to prevent rust from setting in. It also brings out the shine on wooden handles.

Hacksaw. Useful for trimming handles (or sawing them off altogether if they need replacement).

Hammer and steel punch. With this combination you can push the old handle stub out of the tool eye. Punches of the right size can be improvised from 8"-12" nails (cut the point off with a hacksaw).

Sharpening stone. Good for reshaping chisels and other edged tools.

Vise. Useful for holding onto your work, but if you haven't got one, a bunch of different-sized wooden blocks will do.



A Few Common Hand Tools

Hammers and mallets:

There are two main types of striking tools for armour-making -- soft-faced (wood, rawhide, lead) and hard hammers. Usually the second-hand wooden mallets are scuffed-up and grungy, and they may not be a good bargain -- check to make sure they're free of cracks. I saw a homemade lead mallet, but decided not to get it because I don't really want that much toxic metal sitting around my house. The hard hammers most useful for armouring are around 0.5 to 3 lbs (8 to 48 oz., or ~0.2 to 1.5 kg): several armourers have told me that they get the most use out of the 16-32 oz. range.

The most common repair to hammers is replacing a loose or cracked wooden handle. Saw the remaining wood off nearly flush with the head. Resist the temptation to burn it out with a blowtorch (ruins the temper). Instead, pop it into the oven, on LOW heat (less than 250 deg. F). Leave it there for about half an hour, until the metal expands. Wearing oven mitts, take the head out, put it upside-down in a vise or on wooden blocks, and hammer a flat-ended punch into the bottom of the eye. The handle end should pop out of the top. (Save it, because it's a useful guide.) When fitting the new handle, if you warm the head up before tapping in the wooden wedge, the shrinkage should assure a snug fit. Saw the wood off smoothly across the top of the eye, then hammer in the metal wedge(s) to anchor it.

Here are some common steel hammer types:
1) Claw hammer (<0.5 to 2 lbs.) -- the > 1 lb. types are often framing hammers with a milled or "waffled" face
2) Engineer's ball-peen (0.5 to 2.5 lbs., in 0.25 lb. increments)
3) Tack hammer (0.25 to 0.5 lbs.)
4) Club hammer or mallet (2.5 to 4 lbs.) -- a short-handled mini-sledge
5) Brick hammer (1 to 1.5 lbs) -- flat-faced square head with a long chisel-like cross-peen
6) Sledge hammer (2.5 lbs. up) -- longer handle and more elongated head than a club hammer

Keep a lookout for blacksmithing hammers, too. All of the hammer types listed above can be used for pounding sheet metal, or riveting. Various folks have suggested modifications, such as grinding hammer faces (especially if they are 2" or wider) into domes. One armourer suggests that a hammer can be modified for close-quarter work (e.g. inside a helm) by taking a hacksaw to the back part. So a beat-up hammer (even the claw type) can be turned into a useful tool -- a flat or dome-face half-hammer that gives a longer swing under cramped conditions.

And the others:

Punch. Used for making indentations or even holes in sheet metal or leather. The tip may be chipped and the striking end may be burled over. The steel (especially on older ones) can be very good, requiring only some reshaping with a file, and rust removal. They are often on sale for $1 or less.

Hacksaw. The most common types are shaped like a bow, or have a pistol grip. Check to make sure the blade is securely mounted, and can be replaced by store-bought replacements. (You probably know this already, but saw blades designed to cut wood shouldn't be used to cut metal because they aren't good at it, and may cause you injury.)

Chisel (metal/masonry). The "cold" type of chisel is made entirely of steel, and is much sturdier than the kind used for woodworking. Cold chisels are meant to be struck with a hammer or mallet, and are used for cutting or grooving metal. Any ones up for sale may be in rough shape, needing to be reground on both sides, coming to an edge of around 60 degrees.

Chisel (wood). Why even mention wood chisels when theyÕre not meant to be used on metal? Chisels are one way to carve a dishing form into a tree stump. Because it's end-grain wood, this automatically rules out all but the biggest, sturdiest tools of this type. Wood chisels are more delicate than cold chisels -- often the cutting edge will chip, or the internal tang will crack through the wooden handle if they are hammered. Many of the wood chisels put up for sale have been ruined this way. The "firmer" and "mortise" types are made with thick blades and can be tapped with a SOFT mallet (wood, rawhide, or rubber). As a general rule, heavy-duty chisels with impact-resistant plastic handles are probably okay with steel hammers, as long as you use ones under 1 lb. (16 oz.) and tap GENTLY. Don't use ANY kind of hammer if the chisel tang is long and pointed, or if you can't see the tang through the handle, or if the handle is cracked or damaged in any way. All-steel chisels are okay to hit with steel hammers, but ALWAYS wear eye protection regardless.

Axes and Hatchets. Speaking of carving depressions in stumps, a hatchet or shortened axe would do the job too. Before doing anything, take the precaution of making a cardboard blade-guard and swathing that part of the head in duct tape. (Usually secondhand axes are blunt, but I recently found one that was as sharp as a butcher knife. Ow.) Handles can be replaced the same way as for hammers, described below. Sometimes a drywall/lathing hatchet will turn up (half-hatchet, half-hammer). An interesting tool, but it might be better to trade with a drywall contractor for something that doesn't look quite as lethal.

Pliers. These are usually plentiful at garage sales. Both the needlenose and short-jawed varieties are useful for holding work, rolling or flanging edges, and other tasks. Often the handle casings have come off -- this doesn't affect the performance of the pliers, but it can be hard on the hands if you are knitting chainmail, etc. -- wrapping the handles well with tape can help. (Editor's Note: The grips on pliers and other tools can be replaced with a product called "Plasti-Grip," available from hardware stores) The teeth may have worn down -- you can renew them with a triangular file, or flatten them altogether if you don't want them marring the work. If you're looking at vise grips, make sure they change back and forth smoothly between the locked and unlocked positions.

Shears and Cutters. By the time people part with complex things like aviation snips and boltcutters, there's a good chance that something has gone wrong with them. Check for broken tips, chipped blades, and loose rivets or pivot-points. One person I know keeps a length of 14 ga. wire and a small bit of 18 ga. sheet metal in his pocket at all times for covert testing of these kinds of tools. Carpenter's pincers and end-nippers may need their jaws filed to new angles to make a straighter cut for chainmail rings.

Hand Drills. The type of hand-powered drill to keep an eye out for is the breast drill. It is heavier and more powerful than the ordinary hurdy-gurdy, and not as cumbersome as the bit brace. The really old breast drills have circular plates at the end, to lean on as you drill into the work. The more recent models have oval or saddle-shaped plates. The gear system is generally so simple that it takes a long time to wear out -- the first thing to start going wrong seems to be the chuck that holds the drill bits (usually a 3-piece Barber chuck). In combination with a punch to make a depression or even a small hole in the metal, a breast drill equipped with a fancy new drill bit can go through (mild) steel plate fairly quickly. I haven't tried it on the heavier gauges yet, but based on what I've seen so far, this sort of thing would be okay, as long as you didn't require a whole lot of holes. It's slightly more period, it'll work even if you have no access to electrical power, and it's a lot cheaper than the battery-operated drills on the market.



Measurement Devices

Cloth measuring tape (the kind used for sewing). These are actually more appropriate for taking armour-fitting measurements than the flexible rulers used for carpentry.

Steel rule. Unless they have been treated very roughly, metal rulers hold up better than wooden or plastic ones over time. Inspect them to make sure the steel is not too warped or nicked to serve as a straight edge (sometimes people have wrecked them in mock swordfights). If the etched or stamped numbers are deeper than the surface corrosion, the metal can be sanded clean, polished with automotive sandpaper (600 or finer), and oiled lightly.

Calipers. The odds are against finding the fancy kind with the built-in scale, but there are a lot of former art students who are looking to unload the basic no-frills plastic/aluminum model held together with a simple bolt. If you find a pair that can take an inside or outside measurement of 10" (25 cm) or more, they would be very useful for fitting armour (especially helms). The outside type have more of a curve to them, but can also be adjusted to take some inside measurements.

Fishing pull-scales. They don't take up much space, but are useful for estimating the weight of materials and finished pieces of armour.



Improvised Tools

Here is a list of useful items which sometimes turn up at second-hand sales, and can be pressed into service as tools:

Trailer hitch. These come in sizes ranging from about 1.5 to 2.5 inches in diameter, and can be made into ball stakes or hammers (for raising or dishing metal and leather). The old-fashioned kind which are rounded rather than flattened on top are the best, but the new ones can be ground into a curve. They can be secured by welding, or using pre-threaded metal rods.

Thick pieces of steel plate. Several years ago my dad picked up a piece of steel, about the size of a paperback novel but around half an inch thick. I don't know what it was used for, or where he found it, but it's great as a striking surface.

Chunks of railroad track. Sometimes railway workers take home discarded track offcuts to use as doorstops. These can make decent anvil substitutes.

Heavy steel plumbing pipe. I haven't tried this out yet, but it might be possible to contruct a T-shaped stake using a T-junction and short bits of pipe. Could be useful for bending metal strips (e.g. for Roman armour).

Mooring cleat. These sometimes turn up in port cities. I found one here in Victoria which was as big around as my wrist and must have weighed at least ten kilos -- looked like an skinny anvil with long horns.

Shotputs, ornamental iron finials (knobs). All of these have been suggested as acceptable substitutes for large-sized ball stakes, in the four-inch range. If you are thinking of raising helmets in one piece, you will need something larger, at least six inches in diameter, preferably seven or eight. They're out there -- cannonballs, etc.



Summary

My goal is to assemble a set of hand tools suitable for armouring, with a price ceiling of $20 (Cdn) for each one. So far, I've acquired a drill, a hacksaw, several pairs of pliers, three different-sized punches, a hatchet that I'm hoping to reshape into a historic pattern (the way John Steinbeck did when he was working on his Arthurian book), a 1" plastic-handled firmer chisel, and more hammers than I really need -- all for under $100. Most of these tools are "previously owned", and while many of them have seen better days, others (the Montreal-made Ryall drill, and the Stanley hammer) are downright handsome. I could get everything else I want next week for another $100, but I'm having so much fun just hunting around for used stuff that I'm going to keep on doing this through the garage sale and street market season -- who knows what else will turn up?



Bibliography

Jackson, Albert, and Day, David. 1992. Tools and how to use them. Wings Books: New York.

Klenman, Allan. 1990. Axe makers of North America. Whistle Punk Books: Victoria B.C.

Taylor, Jeff. 1996. Tools of the trade. Chronicle: San Francisco.




THE ARADOR ARMOUR LIBRARY
Webmaster:
Eric Slyter
Assistant Forum Moderators: Mike Brock, Kara Frost-Slyter, Glen Kyle, Ron McWilliams, W. Reid Ripley, Christian H. Tobler, Dave Womble
Forum Archive: Marcus Grymme

No part of this site nor it's content may be reproduced without permission from The Arador Armour Library.
Please see our Legal Disclaimer.

Copyright 1995-2003 by The Arador Armour Library